The phasing out of lifetime tenancies will not negatively impact protected demographic groups overall, the government has said.
According to Inside Housing:
“The government is proposing phasing out lifetime tenancies for new social tenants and instead requiring landlords to offer fixed-term tenancies. The government announced last week that social landlords would be able to offer lifetime tenancies for “up to 10 years”, rather than five years as originally proposed.
In its equalities impact assessment published yesterday, the Department for Communities and Local Government (DCLG) assessed the potential impact of the policy on several demographic groups, including older people, younger people, families, people with disabilities, ethnic minorities and women.
It said: “While it is possible that there may be some negative impacts on some members of protected groups, for instance increasing concerns about future security of tenure where their housing need is marginal, this is outweighed by the wider benefits to protected groups as a whole.
“All the protected groups should benefit from better use of the social rented stock and from the regular assessment of tenants’ circumstances that should ensure a better fit between the household and their social home.” Inside Housing has asked DCLG for more information about the methodology used for the impact assessment.
The government is expected to publish guidance on the use of 10-year tenancies later in the year. However, the equalities impact assessment states: “Five years will be the normal maximum (for households without children of school age), with 10 years applicable for those with longer-term needs, such as older people, the disabled and their carers.”
The assessment said older people are “much more likely” to under-occupy their social rented home. It said 58% lifetime tenancies for under-occupying households had a tenant aged 60 or over compared to 36% of social rented houses overall. It said older people will benefit from the policy because it will make it “easier for social landlords to support older tenants’ move to more manageable-sized accommodation, freeing up larger homes for families”.
Younger people are “overrepresented” in social housing compared to other age groups, according to the assessment. It said 21% of lettings were made to people aged 18 to 24 in 2013/14.
The assessment concluded: “There is a potential for them to benefit from the increased freedom for landlords to offer shorter-term tenancies (i.e. between two and five years), where for example landlords use them to support young people into work.”
The government conceded there may be a negative impact on individuals who are forced to leave a tenancy, but “the policy will not have a substantial impact on discrimination overall”.
“The policy should have benefits for the wider community by ensuring a fair distribution of a limited, subsidised resource,” it added.”